В чем разница minecraft java edition и windows 10 edition

После того, как Minecraft для PlayStation 4 получила обновление Bedrock, владельцы этой консоли наконец смогли играть с пользователями других платформ благодаря кроссплею. Экосистема игры начинает принимать тот вид, который давно запланировали разработчики.

Однако даже несмотря на то, что теперь все издания Minecraft для платформ нынешнего поколения находятся в одном семействе, среди версий игры всё равно есть путаница. Например, Minecraft на 3DS (да, есть и такая) развивается отдельно от остальных, а на ПК параллельно существуют аж две версии.

Написали руководство обо всех существующих ныне изданиях Minecraft, а также их различиях.

Какие есть версии игры

Minecraft: Java Edition

Платформы: ПК (Windows, Mac, Linux, Ubuntu)

Java Edition — это именно тот Minecraft, который изначально начал разрабатывать Маркус Перссон в 2009 году. Можно сказать, что это «флагманское» издание, поддерживаемое разработчиками в первую очередь — даже несмотря на то, что в неё играет меньше людей.

Преимущества:

Недостатки:

Важно учесть, что Java Edition — одна из двух версий, доступных на ПК. Об отличиях второго издания с Java будет описано ниже.

Minecraft: Bedrock Edition

Платформы: Android, iOS, Windows 10 Mobile, PlayStation 4, Xbox One, Nintendo Switch, Windows 10 и некоторые другие.

Где купить: в магазинах платформ.

Фактически, Bedrock Edition — это не порт, а заново разработанная игра. Её создавали на другой архитектуре (C++ вместо Java) для удобства переноса на другие платформы.

Долгое время мобильные и консольные версии существовали и развивались раздельно, пока в 2018 не получили обновление Bedrock — теперь все апдейты на них выходят разом, а пользователи с разных устройств могут играть вместе.

Преимущества:

Недостатки:

Какая версия для Windows 10 лучше

Зависит от того, что требуется — так как все фичи с Java Edition присутствуют и в Windows 10 Edition. Хоть и до последней апдейты доходят чуть дольше.

Если вам важен перенос прогресса между платформами, то, конечно, стоит выбрать Windows 10 Edition — иного способа перенести игровую карту с ПК на смартфоны нет.

Однако в таком случае вы не сможете ставить моды, заходить на ПК-серверы и делать всё то, что на Java Edition было доступно ещё со времён альфа- и бета-тестирования.

Также из мелких достоинств Windows 10 Edition стоит выделить то, что она поддерживает управление контроллером с Xbox One, а также меньше тормозит — из-за того, что работает на C++, а не на Java.

Важный момент: Windows 10 Edition не будет запускаться на Xbox One, и наоборот. Её нужно докупать отдельно.

О каких ещё версиях стоит знать

While exploring the enchanting universe of Minecraft, have you ever faced the perplexing decision between Minecraft Java vs Windows 10? If so, this detailed guide will answer you.

Minecraft is among the most popular mission game. Mojang Studios developed the sandbox game in 2011 using Java, but many things have changed since the game first came into the scene.

If you’re a regular Minecraft player, you enjoy a particular version or love to play both. If you’re considering purchasing it, you must choose between the game’s Windows 10 version (also called Bedrock) and Java Edition.

Understandably, it’s easy to feel confused, especially since both game versions share numerous similarities. One wouldn’t think that the two editions are different. However, they vary, offering unique features, capabilities, and game experience.

So what’s the difference between the two? This guide highlights the significant differences between Minecraft Java vs Minecraft for Windows to help you make an informed decision.

Table of Content

1. Minecraft Java Edition: An Overview
2. Minecraft Windows 10 Edition: An Overview
3. Minecraft Java vs Windows: A Comparative Analysis
4. Choosing the Right Edition: Minecraft Java vs Windows in Today’s Gaming Landscape
5. Conclusion
6. FAQs

Minecraft Java Edition: An Overview

Minecraft Java Edition is the first version of the popular sandbox video game, initially released in 2011. Mojang Studios developed and designed this game strictly for personal computers. It is written in Java, and you can play it on Linux, macOS, and Windows 7, 8, and 10.

What makes this version stand out in the Minecraft Java edition vs Minecraft for Windows? The features section will answer you.

Key Features of Minecraft Java Edition

Here’s a comprehensive overview of Minecraft Java Edition’s features and capabilities:

• Extensive modding support – The first standout feature of the Minecraft Java Edition is its vast and active modding community. This capability allows players to add custom content, gameplay mechanics, and visual enhancements through different mod types.
• Early snapshot access – This version will give you early access to development snapshots. Consequently, testing upcoming features and updates before their official release is easy.
• Customizable servers – Minecraft Java Edition makes it easy for players to set up and join private or public servers. Thus, you’ll have more control over your multiplayer experience.
• Resource packs and shaders – It’s easy to install and use Minecraft Java’s custom resource packs to change the game’s textures and appearance. What’s more, you can improve lighting and visual effects using shaders.
• Dedicated community servers – This version of Minecraft boasts a rich ecosystem of community-run servers. It comprises unique gameplay modes, mini-games, and adventures.
• Redstone mechanics – This special Minecraft capability enables you to create complex machines, automation systems, and contraptions within the game.
• Java-based – This version of Minecraft is Java-based. Therefore, it can run on a wide range of operating systems.

Minecraft Windows 10 Edition: An Overview

The Windows 10 Minecraft version is based on the Bedrock edition. This essentially refers to a video game version that came slightly later than the Java Edition and uses the C programming language. The version is the brainchild of Xbox Game Studios and Mojang Studio. It’s available for any device that runs Windows 10, mobile devices, and consoles.

Key Features of Minecraft Windows 10 Edition

Here are some of the notable features of Minecraft Windows 10 edition:

• Cross-platform gameplay – Players can seamlessly join and interact with others across multiple devices. You can play it via Windows 10 PCs, Nintendo Switch, Xbox One, Android, and iOS.
• Marketplace – This version of the game grants you access to the in-game Minecraft Marketplace. You can purchase and download community-created skins, texture packs, worlds, and mash-up packs here.
• Minecraft Realms – This vital feature of Minecraft Windows 10 allows players to set up and manage their own private servers. As a result, it becomes easier for friends to play together even when the host is offline.
• Performance optimizations – Minecraft’s Bedrock Edition is generally better optimized than its Java counterpart. It stands out with smoother gameplay, especially on lower-end devices.
• Touchscreen support – This edition works well with touchscreen devices. Users now have a convenient and intuitive way to play on tablets and touch-enabled PCs.
• Updated graphics – Minecraft for Windows 10 isn’t as extensive in mods as in the Java Edition. However, it comes with enhanced graphics, lighting, and water effects.
• Command blocks and add-ons – This version of Minecraft allows you to create custom worlds and use command blocks to manipulate the game. In addition, the add-ons allow players to modify behaviors and textures.

Minecraft Java vs Windows: A Comparative Analysis

From the first look, one would think that the debate between Minecraft Java edition and Windows edition is fair. This is because the two versions are deceptively similar. However, this isn’t the case, as several fundamental features and capabilities can tell the devices apart.

Let’s get straight into it:

Gameplay Experience

The first distinguishing factor in the Minecraft Windows vs Java debate is the gameplay experience. Generally, Minecraft Java is the original version with a strong modding community and timely updates. It’s great for customizing the game and getting new features quickly. On the other hand, Minecraft Windows 10 is better for playing with friends on different devices, and it runs smoother on lower-end computers.

Modding Capabilities

The two Minecraft editions support mods but have multiple subtle and vivid differences. The Java version debuted in 2010, boasting a larger modding community than the Windows 10 version released in 2015. Moreover, the Java mods are superior to those of Windows 10. The latter was initially intended for mobile devices. Also, its modding options are not as big as Java’s because it uses the Microsoft Store for add-ons. As a result, it lags in the modding scene.

Crossplay Compatibility

This is among the key distinguishing features in the Minecraft Windows 10 vs Java debate. The Windows 10 Edition boasts superior crossplay capabilities than its peers. This version is part of the Bedrock platform, so players can seamlessly connect and play with others across various devices. You can use it on Windows 10 PCs, Xbox One, Nintendo Switch, iOS, and Android. This crossplay functionality enables a more diverse and accessible multiplayer experience. On the contrary, Minecraft Java Edition does not directly support crossplay with other platforms. Therefore, it limits its multiplayer options to players on the same Java Edition version and platform.

Cost and Updates

Minecraft’s Windows 10 edition may cost you a maximum of $7.99. On the other hand, the Java Edition costs $29.99, a one-time purchase.

However, you can play the Java version fully without paying a dime. In addition, while you can download both variants for free in Windows 10, they come with crucial in-app purchases.

Both versions have their rumors regarding updates. But the truth is Mojang releases regular updates for either version simultaneously. Therefore, you don’t have to worry about losing access to fresh content. Whichever option you choose, you’ll always be up-to-date.

Controls

Controls also come into play in the Minecraft Java edition vs Windows discussion. Players who enjoy managing the game through controllers can have a better experience with the Windows 10 version of Minecraft. The Java version only offers mouse and keyboard support. Its Windows counterpart enhances the gameplay with the freedom to use the mouse, keyboard, and controller.

Servers

The difference between Java vs Windows 10 Minecraft is evident in the two gameplay servers. Both versions offer various multiplayer options. The Java Edition has a more extensive selection of servers since it’s older and has a larger player base. At the same time, the server options in Minecraft Windows 10 Edition are continually evolving. Notably, players using Minecraft Java Edition can only play, interact, and have fun with other players using the same Java Edition. This applies to Minecraft Windows 10 Edition players, as the game doesn’t support cross-play between the two editions.

Choosing the Right Edition: Minecraft Java vs Windows in Today’s Gaming Landscape

In the Minecraft Java vs Windows debate, many overlook the most crucial factor for a great gaming experience – the machine servers hosting  the game. 

Dedicated server hosting for gaming, especially Minecraft, requires expert knowledge of how do servers work, what is web hosting and how does it work in the context of hosting game engines. Server hosting is a complicated subject where you need to know about server types and how they benefit Minecraft game hosting.

Many experts recommend managed dedicated servers you can customize for your Minecraft games. These servers are often custom-built bare metal servers the hosting provider manages on your behalf. You don’t have to worry about server renting, operations, and related details in this arrangement. 

RedSwitches is one of the best dedicated server hosting providers for Minecraft game servers. We offer the best dedicated server pricing and deliver instant dedicated servers, usually on the same day the order gets approved. Whether you need a dedicated server, a traffic-friendly 10Gbps dedicated server, or a powerful bare-metal server, we are your trusted bare metal server hosting partner.

We also recommend reading more about the VPS vs shared hosting, Unix vs Linux, and Debian vs Fedora to make informed decisions about your Minecraft servers. 

Conclusion

As we sum up our Minecraft Java edition vs Windows 10 debate, you know what side befits your gaming needs. Generally, the main differences between these two games are in their gameplay experiences, modding capabilities, and crossplay features.

The Java Edition offers a robust modding community with extensive customization options and superior graphics. Other features that make it stand apart are extensive modding support, dedicated community servers, and early snapshot access.

On the other hand, its Windows 10 counterpart excels in its classic Minecraft experience and cross-platform compatibility. Other impressive features include an in-game marketplace, updated graphics, and cross-platform gameplay. You can also play it on your smartphone device and console.

With this knowledge, you can decide what’s right for you between Minecraft Java vs Windows. You can only get the best experience when you partner with a reliable gaming server provider like RedSwitches. We offer solutions for both versions, guaranteeing seamless gaming and exceptional performance.

FAQs

Q-1) Is Minecraft Java Better Than Windows?

Whether Minecraft Java beats its Windows counterpart will depend on your individual preferences. Generally, the former boasts extensive modding support and better graphics, while the latter excels in crossplay and accessibility across different devices.

Q-2) What Is The Difference Between Minecraft Windows And Java?

The two-game versions have distinct differences. However, their main difference lies in their modding capabilities and crossplay features. Java generally has a larger modding community, while Windows provides a seamless multiplayer experience.

Q-3) Which Minecraft Version Is The Best?

The Minecraft Java edition vs Minecraft for Windows debate has no definitive “best” version. Rather, this decision varies based on individual preferences. Having said that, [8] [9] Minecraft Java offers more customization and mods, while the Windows 10 edition excels in cross-platform play and accessibility.

Q-4) Is Bedrock Harder Than Java?

No. The difficulty level between Bedrock and Java versions of Minecraft is fairly on par. Of course, there are slight variations in mechanics and gameplay, but neither is inherently more difficult.

Q-5) Is Minecraft Windows 10 Easier To Run Than Java?

Yes. The Windows 10 edition of Minecraft is generally easier to run than Java. In addition, it is better optimized and supports cross-platform play on various devices. Consequently, it’s more accessible to a wider range of hardware configurations.

Лев Савчук
06.05.2020

На windows 10 позже выходят релизы и беты, так как Она больше оптимизирована, но она кросс-платформ, по ней можно общаться, как в мессенджерах (в отдельном приложении), в ней ты можешь на дальнем расстоянии играть по xbox, без портов, hamachi (или, как там, я по ней ни разу не играл), в пе (она же десята, но я говорю о пе) можно на пиратках играть с лицензией, но на ней нет читов, на нее хостинги дороже, их меньше. Джава менее оптимизированная, но на нее больше читов, модов, как по мне, на джава тяжелее писать, чем на пе моды. На ней сложно сменить ник, на нее чаще и больше выходят беты (снапшоты), на нее легче написать плагин (опять же, как по мне), легче запустить сервер на пк, на нее есть оптик, больше и лучше шейдеры, больше серверов, на ней больше миниигр, карт. И это еще не все, но большая часть — тут…

Do you want to have a great game experience at a reasonable price? If your answer is positive, this post of MiniTool is worth reading carefully. This article will tell you whether you should choose Windows 10 or Java edition from several aspects.

Introduction

Minecraft originally was a game based on Java until Microsoft purchased it. The Java edition is still in active state condition, but since Minecraft is a popular game title, using it as a UWP app is a great way to promote these types of apps.

In terms of functionality, Minecraft Windows 10 is similar to Java version. We refer to the various items that appear in the game, monsters and biomes, and its general mechanics by function. That is to say, there are differences between games and affect the game to a large extent.

-image from minecraft.net

Therefore, which one is the best versions of Minecraft? Minecraft Windows 10 or the original Java? It is not easy to conclude, but you are able to get some clues after reading the comparison between the two versions.

Further reading:

For meeting the different demands of users, the developer of Minecraft makes several versions. The available Minecraft versions and their compatible devices are listed as follows. According to your device type, get a proper Minecraft version.

• Minecraft for PC (Java Edition) – Windows, Mac, and Linux
• Minecraft Pocket Edition – Android and iOS included
• Minecraft Windows 10 (now the Bedrock Edition) – Windows 10 and above, mobile devices, consoles, VR headsets
• Minecraft for the web (Classic edition) – Windows, Mac, and Linux
• Minecraft for consoles – PlayStation, Xbox, and Nintendo
• Minecraft for education

You may also like: Minecraft Bedrock vs Java Edition PC Download (Either or Both)

Minecraft Windows 10 VS Java

The comparison between Minecraft Windows 10 and Java version mainly contains six aspects. They are Mods, Costs, Controls, Crossplay, Servers and system resource consumption respectively. Now, I will explain them one by one for you

Mods:

Two versions of Minecraft support mod. That is, since the appearance of Java version from 2010, there are more mods available in the first version compared with the 2015 Windows 10 version. Objectively speaking, the quality of Java mode is higher than the standard of Minecraft Windows 10 mods.

After all, the original edition of Windows 10 version was designed for mobile devices, so the modified scene will always be catching up.

Costs:

The cost of the Java Edition in the UK is £17.95, while Windows 10 Edition will cost you £22.49 in the Windows Store.

But there is a little bit. The Java version can be fully played, complete with mods, textures, and all other content associated with Minecraft without paying a penny. Although you can download all of the above variants for free in Windows 10, this version also includes optional in-game purchases.

These items range from map packs, textures, skins and new game modes. Most people will definitely oppose the idea of paying for addons in Minecraft, but for parents, since the third-party content of Windows 10 has been reviewed by Microsoft, it is a risk-free approach.

Controls:

Both versions support mice and keyboards, but only one of them supports controllers. Though Mojang was released in 2010, it has not yet implemented the Java version of the controller support.

For most PC-centric players, this won’t be a problem, but if you want to jump from the darkness of the console game to the PC, you’ll need to install an additional program such as Joy ToKey, to get a controller.

On Windows 10 Edition, you plug in a controller and it will work. Even if you don’t use the controller feature, in this case, more features are better than fewer.

Crossplay:

On the Windows release, anyone can play with players on other devices including Xbox, Android, IOS and the Nintendo Switch in June. When playing games with other players, you need to register a free Xbox Live account. As this function is not available for the Java edition, Minecraft Windows 10 edition has an absolute advantage.

Servers:

Two versions have servers. The only problem is that we are using two different versions of the same game – the Java edition cannot connect to the Windows 10 server, while Windows 10 cannot connect to the server of Java edition.

Hence, the key point of selecting an edition is to see which has more servers you like.

System resource consumption:

The Java edition of Minecraft is more resource intensive than the Windows 10 edition. This is more like a Java issue than a Minecraft issue. This is because that Java edition of Minecraft is a full application while the Windows 10 edition is a Minecraft PE or a mobile one. You will find that Java Minecraft is not so resource-consuming after comparing it with other full applications games such as Fortenite, Apex Legends, Creativerse, etc.

Therefore, if you don’t want to modify the game further, using the Windows 10 edition is a better idea.

That is all the contents of Minecraft Java edition vs Windows 10. It’s a great reference for you.